Woman in a Queer State
Posted in Life, Queer, Woman on July 17th, 2008 7 Comments »
I wore a three-piece suit to my community college graduation ceremony over 10 years ago. I was just a baby really, beginning the long discovery of my strange and fascinating gender identity. I felt this was my breakthrough moment, the very first time I left the house wearing something so obviously, and loudly male. I was embracing a long held desire to dress formally in masculine attire, and I was proud of it.
Unfortunately, not everyone shared my enthusiasm. I waited and waited for my mom to show up at the graduation, but she never came. When I went home to my parents’ house, worried out of my mind, my father told me that she had seen me leaving the house in a suit and had experienced such an intense, emotional reaction, that she had been unable to come to my graduation. After confronting my mother, I stood in the driveway and cried harder than I’ve ever cried in my life. I had broken my mother’s heart by being gender queer, and she had broken mine by being offended by a part of me I was no longer willing to ignore.
I’m really not sure how much of my mother’s revulsion to my gender expression was based in fear of the queer, so to speak, or if she was only wildly disappointed in my attempts to cross over into the male identity. My mother is a feminist, and she taught me well of the patriarchy, which to her represents repression, unchecked power, arrogance, greed, control, and injustice to women everywhere. She would tell me later that it was the vision of her daughter in a three-piece suit specifically that gave her such a shock, attire in her mind only worn by power-hungry corporate executive types who have little to no respect for women in general.
So many times since I began wondering about gender have I thought that perhaps I am, in fact, a man trapped in a woman’s body. I’ve pondered excitedly the idea of going all the way, taking testosterone, becoming physically as much of a man as is possible in today’s vast landscape of medical and social possibilities. I’ve watched a lot of my gender queer friends do just that, or some version of that, growing facial hair, going bald, beefing up, and passing as men, a clear realization of the gender that drives them from within.
Unfortunately (or fortunately) for me, it’s never been simple. Although most of me happily basks in the knowledge that I’m special and freaky, a part of me yearns so much to be just another normal person, someone who doesn’t conjure fear and confusion in the minds of the common people. If I were a man, everything would be so much easier, I think to myself: I could marry my girlfriend anywhere, I could finally have a manly, muscular body, I wouldn’t feel as vulnerable, I’d fit in with ease, I could grow some side burns, etc. It would be amazing to watch my body and my perspective change as a result of injecting hormones. I would finally and absolutely know what it was like to live as a man in this world, and I would surely enjoy all those benefits that come with male privilege.
There’s some other part of me, though, that has stopped me every time I’ve come close to beginning a physical transition. I went as far as to make an appointment to begin hormone injections a few years ago, but realized at the last minute that it just wasn’t the right thing for me to do. It may be childhood brainwashing, it may be fear of the unknown, it may be any number of subconscious lines of reason that I will never be able to fully comprehend. All I really know is that I am a woman more than I am a man, no matter how full of penis envy I might be. I may be a representation of a new kind of woman, an atypical reminder of the fallibility of a binary gender system, a slap in the face to traditional female roles, and a poster child for the next (and perhaps, sadly, the last) generation of butch dykes.
Unfortunately, it appears to me that my particular situation is only a jumping off point for most gender queer folks of my age and younger. I felt angry and betrayed as a young dyke discovering the butch community. I watched my peers and role models changing into something else, something I had no desire to be, and I felt left behind and alone. The more I hear about queer kids rejecting anything with feminine associations, the more disappointed (and worried) I become.
I believe we live in a misogynistic society. I realize that a lot has changed over the past hundred years, “we’ve come a long way baby”, and all that, but I still see the sickness pervading our world. One of the most obvious symptoms is the self-inflicted hatred that all women seem to share. So many of my fellow queers are more than willing to date and love women, but refuse to allow themselves to express a gender that ever reflects any sort of womanness at all. We instead choose to mirror the typical man whose masculinity is in question, becoming righteously offended and defensive against anyone who dares to perceive us as female: using the incorrect pronoun, including us in the collective “we” when referring to “us women” or “girls night out”.
I am by no means trying to submit that my trans friends who identify as he, man, male, and him deserve any less respect or acknowledgment as the gender they have chosen. Every single person deserves to be perceived exactly as they desire, as much as that is possible by our limited psychic and communicative abilities. Many of my queer brethren rock the same fence I do, and have ended up on the other side. I will continue to support them in whatever identities they choose to explore and discover for themselves. Above all, we must support each other.
Perhaps that is why I worry. I worry that an already difficult experience as a woman (and as a queer) has made transitioning an all too obvious assumption for those that grow up confused about where their gender fits into the inflexibility that is mainstream America. I worry that the only way we know to support each other is to provide transitioning as the only solution to our dissatisfaction with the state of our body and mind. Are there any other solutions (besides taking hormones and having surgery) that will help us to feel good (or at least alright) about who we are?
For a lot of queer people I know, gender identity is a complex, personal experience, full of hope, introspection, pain, need, self-love, curiosity, wonderment, and confusion. It’s never simple, and it’s never the same for any two people. Gender is just a part of all the other stuff that makes us who we are, a neverending, beautiful web of expression, identity, and understanding. Here’s to the continuing journey of our own discovery as well as the ongoing support of all of our queer brothers, sisters, and others.


